How RSUs Are Taxed (and How to Check Yours with AI)
How RSUs and stock options are taxed in the US, what you owe at vest, exercise and sale, plus a prompt that has AI explain your own grants.
For Executives, Finance and Managers

How are RSUs taxed?
In the US, RSUs (restricted stock units) are taxed as ordinary income on the day they vest. The taxable amount is the number of shares that vest times the market price that day. It is taxed like salary: federal income tax, Social Security and Medicare, and usually state tax. That amount appears on your W-2. When you later sell the shares, you owe capital gains tax only on the change in price since vesting.
This article covers the US. Other countries tax equity differently, and your state, your employer's plan and your situation all change the details. Treat everything here as a way to understand your numbers and ask better questions, not as tax advice.
TL;DR
- RSUs are taxed at vest, not at grant or sale. The full value of the shares on the vest date counts as wages, even if you never sell a share.
- Your employer's withholding is often too low for senior earners. Federal supplemental withholding is a flat rate, which can be well under your real marginal bracket.
- Your cost basis is the price on the vest date. If you sell later, only the gain or loss from that price is a capital gain or loss, and the holding period starts at vest.
- Stock options work differently. NSOs are taxed at exercise on the spread, and ISOs get special treatment that can trigger the alternative minimum tax (AMT).
- Brokerage tax forms often show the wrong basis for RSUs. Check the 1099-B against your W-2 so you don't pay tax twice on the same income.
- AI is good at explaining and modeling your grants and bad at being your source of truth. Give it your numbers, make it show its math, and verify against your documents and a tax professional.
What happens at each stage of an RSU?
An RSU is a promise to deliver shares if you meet conditions, usually staying employed through a vest schedule. There are three taxable moments to understand.
| Stage | Tax event? | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Grant | No | You receive the promise. Nothing is taxed. |
| Vest | Yes | Value of vested shares is ordinary income. Taxes are withheld. |
| Sale | Yes, on the change | Gain or loss versus the vest-date price is a capital gain or loss. |
Two consequences surprise people. First, you owe tax at vest even if the stock then falls. If 1,000 shares vest at $50 and the price drops to $30 the next week, you still reported $50,000 of income. Second, if your company is private, RSUs often have two conditions (a time condition and a liquidity event such as an IPO). In that case the tax event usually comes when both are met, which can create a large bill on shares you cannot yet sell. Check your grant agreement.
How is the tax at vest actually collected?
Your employer must withhold tax when shares vest. There are two common methods, and your plan will use one of them:
- Sell to cover. The broker sells enough of the vesting shares to pay the withholding and deposits the rest in your account.
- Net share settlement. The company keeps back shares worth the withholding and delivers the remainder.
Either way, you receive fewer shares than vested, but you are taxed on all of them.
The catch is the rate. The IRS treats RSU income as supplemental wages, and employers can withhold federal income tax on it at a flat rate (currently 22% for supplemental wages up to $1 million in a year, with a higher mandatory rate above that). If your marginal bracket is higher than the flat rate, which is common for senior finance staff, managers and executives, withholding will fall short. You settle the difference when you file, or in the quarterly estimated payments you should have made.
Other taxes come out too. Social Security tax applies up to an annual wage limit, and you may already be past it by the time a late-year vest happens. Medicare tax has no limit, and an additional Medicare tax applies to wages above a threshold based on filing status. State and local income taxes vary widely.
What is a worked example of RSU taxes?
These numbers are invented to show the mechanics. Yours will differ.
You are in a high federal bracket. 1,000 RSUs vest on March 15 when the stock is $50.
- Income at vest: 1,000 x $50 = $50,000, added to your W-2 wages.
- Withholding: the employer withholds federal tax at the flat supplemental rate, plus Medicare, Social Security (if you are under the wage limit) and state tax.
- The gap: if your actual marginal federal rate is higher than the withholding rate, you owe the difference at filing. On $50,000, each 10 points of difference is $5,000.
- Cost basis: $50 per share, $50,000 total for the 1,000 shares.
- Sale: you sell 400 shares the next September at $60. Proceeds are $24,000, basis is $20,000, and the gain is $4,000.
- Holding period: it started at vest. September is under a year later, so the gain is short-term and taxed at ordinary rates. Hold more than a year and it is long-term, which has lower rates. High earners may also owe the 3.8% net investment income tax on gains above a threshold.
If you sell on the vest day at $50, the gain is zero. Many people do this deliberately to avoid concentrated stock risk, and it makes the tax simple: you only owe tax on the income.
Why does my 1099-B look wrong?
This is the most common RSU mistake. When shares are sold, your broker sends a 1099-B showing proceeds and cost basis. For RSUs, the basis reported to the IRS is sometimes zero or just the wrong number, because the broker does not always reflect the income your employer already put on your W-2.
If you file with a basis of zero, you pay tax on the full sale proceeds a second time. The fix is to report the correct basis (the vest-date value, which is on your W-2 income and your equity portal's release records) using the adjustment column on Form 8949. Tax software has a spot for this. Compare three documents each year: your W-2, the 1099-B, and your equity portal's vest and release history.
How are stock options taxed?
Options give you the right to buy shares at a fixed strike price. The tax depends on the type.
Non-qualified stock options (NSOs). At exercise, the spread (market price minus strike price) times the number of shares is ordinary income, and withholding applies. Your basis becomes the market price at exercise. Later gains or losses are capital gains.
Example: You exercise 2,000 NSOs with a $10 strike when the stock is $40. The spread is $30 x 2,000 = $60,000, taxed as wages. Your basis is $40 per share.
Incentive stock options (ISOs). There is no regular income tax at exercise, but the spread is generally an adjustment item for the alternative minimum tax (AMT), so you can owe AMT even though you sold nothing. What happens at sale depends on timing:
- Qualifying disposition: you sell more than two years after the grant date and more than one year after exercise. The profit above your strike price is generally a long-term capital gain.
- Disqualifying disposition: you sell sooner. Part or all of the gain is taxed as ordinary income, and the rest is a capital gain.
If you paid AMT in an earlier year because of ISO exercises, you may be able to recover some of it later through the AMT credit. This is one of the areas where a professional is worth paying for before you exercise, not after.
Private-company options add another problem: you may owe cash for the strike price and for taxes on shares you can't sell. Model that before you exercise.
How can AI help me understand my own grants?
AI is useful here because the hard part is not the math. It is connecting a grant agreement, a vest schedule, a W-2 and a tax bracket into one picture. A good prompt gets you:
- A plain-English summary of what each grant means for your taxes.
- A year-by-year estimate of income from vests, and the withholding gap.
- A list of questions to take to your tax preparer or equity administrator.
- A check of whether a sale will be short- or long-term.
Before you paste anything, remove your name, Social Security number, account numbers and employer name. Use rounded numbers. Check your employer's policy on sharing equity details with outside tools.
The prompt to paste
You are helping me understand how my equity compensation is taxed in the US. I am not looking for tax advice, I want to understand the mechanics and prepare questions for my tax professional.
My situation:
- Filing status: [single / married filing jointly]
- State: [state]
- Estimated taxable income before equity, this year: [$ amount]
- Estimated federal marginal bracket: [%, or say "not sure"]
My equity:
- RSUs: [number] vesting on [dates], approximate share price [$]. My company uses [sell to cover / net share settlement / not sure].
- Options: [type: NSO / ISO / not sure], [number], strike price [$], expiration [date], current price [$].
- Shares I already hold or sold this year: [details, with approximate dates and prices]
Please do the following:
1. Explain in plain English when each item is taxed and what kind of income it is.
2. Estimate my taxable income from equity this year, showing every calculation step by step.
3. Compare likely withholding with my likely actual tax, and estimate the gap. State every assumption you make about rates.
4. For any sale, tell me whether it would be short-term or long-term and what my cost basis should be.
5. If I hold ISOs, explain whether AMT could apply and what information I'd need to know.
6. List what you are unsure about and the 5 questions I should ask my tax preparer.
Do not guess at numbers I did not give you. Where you need a rate or threshold, say so and tell me where to look it up.
What to check in the answer
- Every number traces back to something you gave it. If a figure appears from nowhere, ask where it came from.
- Rates and thresholds are current. Brackets, withholding rates, wage limits and AMT exemptions change. Confirm against the IRS website or your tax software.
- The model separated income from capital gains. A common error is treating the vest value as a gain, or forgetting that basis equals the vest price.
- It asked about your plan's withholding method. If it assumed one without saying so, correct it.
- The ISO and AMT section is hedged. AMT depends on your whole return, and an AI cannot compute it reliably from a few inputs.
Where not to trust AI
Do not rely on AI for a final tax figure, for the decision of when to exercise ISOs or large option grants, for state or foreign tax rules, or for anything involving a company's special arrangements (acquisitions, tender offers, restricted stock with an 83(b) election, or employment moves between countries). Use it to get oriented and to prepare. Then confirm with your equity administrator and a CPA.
What should I do before each vest or exercise?
- Pull your vest schedule from the equity portal for the next 12 months, with expected share counts.
- Estimate your year's income including those vests, and find your real marginal bracket.
- Calculate the withholding gap. Multiply expected vest income by the difference between your bracket and the withholding rate.
- Set cash aside or adjust your paycheck withholding (a new W-4) or quarterly estimated payments to cover the gap.
- Decide your sale plan in advance. Selling at vest is simple and removes price risk. Holding adds risk and makes you a stock investor as well as an employee.
- Keep records. Save the vest confirmations, W-2, 1099-B and your basis calculations each year.
Could I build my own equity tracker?
If you hold grants across several vest dates, one tracker beats a pile of portal screenshots. Remy, a product agent, can build one from a plain-English description: a small web app with your grants, vest dates, share prices, estimated tax at vest, the withholding gap and a running record of cost basis for each lot. Remy's apps include a database and sign-in, and the code is standard TypeScript in a git repo you own. Remy is a paid platform ($99 a month, or $79 billed annually, with a 30-day free trial) plus AI usage at cost, so for one or two grants a spreadsheet is enough. It starts to make sense when you want a tool built with Remy for your own needs, or one shared across a team.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I pay tax when RSUs are granted?
No. For standard RSUs, nothing is taxed at grant. The tax event is the vest date, when the shares are delivered to you and their value counts as wages.
Why was so much less tax withheld than I owe?
Employers commonly withhold federal income tax on RSU income at a flat supplemental rate. If your actual marginal bracket is higher, the withholding falls short and you owe the balance at filing. Higher earners should consider raising their W-4 withholding or making estimated payments.
Is the tax lower if I hold the shares after they vest?
Not on the vest itself, which is taxed as ordinary income no matter what you do. Holding only affects later gains. If you sell more than a year after vest at a higher price, the gain is long-term and taxed at lower rates. If the stock falls, you may have a capital loss.
What is the difference between ISOs and NSOs for taxes?
NSOs are taxed as ordinary income at exercise on the spread. ISOs have no regular tax at exercise but may trigger AMT, and a sale that meets the holding requirements (two years from grant and one year from exercise) can qualify for long-term capital gains treatment on the profit above the strike price.
Can I use AI to do my equity taxes?
You can use AI to understand the rules, build estimates and prepare questions. Do not use it as the final word on what you owe. Give it only the details it needs, verify its rates against official sources, and have a tax professional confirm large or complicated decisions.
How we source, write, and correct our articles. Editorial standards
Related articles

What to Do With Your RSUs: Taxes, Selling, and Diversifying

How Much to Save for Retirement (Use AI to Check Your Number)

Weekly Family Planner: Plan Your Week in 10 Minutes With AI
